Is the new album a step down, was the ticket price a rip-off, does the cover beat the original, who gets the aux cable on a road trip. Hot takes with a jury.
Jurors are listeners first: gig-goers, playlist makers, a few players and producers. They vote on the argument you bring, whatever they listen to.
How cases are written here: first person, what you heard or paid for, what the disagreement is. Name the sides by the claim ("Worth the price" / "Not at that price"), never "real music" against "noise".