Did the ending earn it, was the remake necessary, is the twist a cheat, which season to skip, whether spoilers after a week are fair game. Film and TV, on trial.

Jurors are the people who argue in the car park after the credits: fans, binge-watchers, a few critics. They vote on the case, not the franchise.

How cases are written here: first person, what you watched, what the argument is and what each side holds. Name the sides by the claim ("The ending works" / "It cheated"), never "gets it" against "doesn't get it".